LONDON (Hollywood Reporter) - If you want to end wars and stuff, Arlo Guthrie always said, you've gotta sing loud; and several of the finest and best-loved performers around sang loud, and well, at London's Live 8 concert Saturday trying to bring an end to poverty.
The free 10-hour show before 200,000 fans in Hyde Park may not succeed in putting a stop to early death in Africa, but at least the world leaders meeting at the G8 conference in Edinburgh, Scotland, this week, who could do something about it, cannot say they weren't told.
The marathon concert was billed as the greatest rock show ever, and it came close, with an emotional richness infused with the incomprehensible but correctable tragedy that is today's Africa. Politicians and economists would have to be completely tone-deaf to miss the point.
The event was a masterful display of technical organization as 26 acts performed mostly 15-minute sets, and it appeared to be largely the demands of international television feeds that caused the show to run over by more than two hours.
Memorable moments came thick and fast, featuring a splendidly reunited Pink Floyd, the fighting-fit remains of the Who, a top-notch R.E.M., a surprisingly moving Dido with Youssou N'Dour, a knock-'em-dead number by the Killers and Paul McCartney in world class form.
Playing together for the first time since 1981, Pink Floyd bassist Roger Waters, lead David Gilmour, drummer Nick Mason and keyboardist Rick Wright looked right at home. They made shimmering deliveries of "Breathe," "Money," "Wish You Were Here" and "Comfortably Numb," even if Gilmour had said earlier that performing with Waters after their long falling out was "like sleeping with the ex-wife."
Pete Townshend and Roger Daltry powered out "Who Are You?" -- now more famous as the theme from TV's "CSI" -- and an extended and quite glorious "Won't Get Fooled Again." Young American band the Killers, dressed in white suits, did just one number, "All These Things That I've Done," but it was a dazzling success, and they may be the breakout stars of the show.
McCartney began and ended the day, closing with smashing versions of "Get Back," "Drive My Car" (with surprise guest George Michael) and "Helter Skelter." Then at the piano he sang "The Long and Winding Road," leading into the chant from "Hey Jude," joined by most of the day's performers and the vast crowd.
McCartney and U2 had started things off with a rousing version of "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" largely because the opening line "It was 20 years ago today ..." evoked memories of the 1985 Live Aid charity show.
Ex-Boomtown Rat Bob Geldof, who was the key organizer of that fundraiser and of Live 8, presided over the Hyde Park concert and even sneaked in a crisp rendition of his hit "I Don't Like Mondays."
U2 and Elton John, each in good form, played early sets so they could rush off to concerts elsewhere. In the first of several examples of amending lyrics to fit the occasion, Bono featured in the song "Beautiful Day" all the cities where concerts were being held, and the crowd immediately joined in.
Coldplay came on with their slow dirges, and Richard Ashcroft joined them for more self-pity in his song "Bittersweet Symphony." Current English pop bad-boy Pete Doherty joined Elton John for a middling treatment of Marc Bolan's "Children of the Revolution."
Somewhat surprisingly, it took the mellow-voiced Dido to fully engage the crowd as her "White Flag" revealed some steely strength in the lyric -- "I will go down with this ship" -- that the vast numbers in the park took up in great volume. They got louder still as Senegalese artist N'Dour joined Dido on her "Thank You" and his "Seven Seconds."
Welsh band the Stereophonics cranked up the volume with some impressively raucous rock, and R.E.M. took the proceedings to another level with their expert mix of precision and showmanship. Michael Stipe, wearing blue makeup around his eyes that resembled a mask, bathed in the audience's rapturous and noisy response to "Everybody Hurts" and "Man on the Moon."
Later, Annie Lennox included a vivid "Sweet Dreams" in her set, and Snoop Dog increased the profanity quotient with his rap performance. Joss Stone and the Scissor Sisters made crowd-pleasing appearances, as did Sting and Velvet Revolver.
Keane, Ms. Dynamite, Travis, UB40, Razorlight and Snow Patrol waved the British flag along with Robbie Williams, who once again demonstrated his mysterious grip on British fans with a self-indulgent set of monotonous songs that had the crowd howling for more.
Madonna and Mariah Carey were each over the top, as you might expect, with mechanical movements and syrupy gushing over the Africans who joined them onstage.
It's churlish to complain, however, on a day that may not have changed the world but certainly will be remembered by all who were there. Clouds had threatened rain all afternoon, but they cleared to allow a beautiful sunset over the mass of humanity in Hyde Park, and it remained dry until after midnight as, with public transport closed, the 200,000 made their way home along the surprisingly harmonious streets of London.